Why Choose an Independent Insurance Agency?

More choices, honest advice, and an agent who works for you, not for one insurance company.

What Is an Independent Insurance Agency?

An independent insurance agency works with multiple insurance companies instead of just one. That means we can compare coverage and prices from several carriers and recommend the policy that fits you best, rather than the only policy we’re allowed to sell.



Sills Insurance Agency has been an independent agency in Dover, Tennessee, since 1952. For more than 70 years, we’ve used that independence to shop the market for our clients and give them real options.

Independent Agency vs. Captive Agent vs. Buying Online

There are three common ways to buy insurance. Here’s how they compare:

Independent Agency Captive Agent Buying Online Direct
Number of insurance companies Several One One per website
Who compares your options Your agent does it for you Only one company’s products are available You do it yourself
Personal advice Yes, from a local agent Yes, limited to one company Usually a call center or chatbot
Help with claims Your agent advocates for you Varies You deal with the company directly
If your rate goes up We can shop your coverage with other companies Your options are limited to that company You start over on your own

The Advantages of Working With Us

Two people walk toward a red barn, pulling a wagon through a green field under a cloudy sky.
Black clipboard with white checkmarks and lines, representing a checklist or to-do list.

More Choices

Because we work with multiple insurance companies, you get to compare options side by side. If one company isn’t the right fit for your home, your business, or your budget, we have others to look at.

Hands holding a lightbulb icon in a black square

Advice That Works for You

We aren’t tied to a single company’s sales goals. Our job is to find the coverage you need, explain it in plain English, and tell you straight if you’re paying for something you don’t need.

Black icon of a person with crossed arms and a head above a torso.

Someone in Your Corner at Claim Time

When something goes wrong, you don’t have to face the insurance company alone. Call us, and we’ll help you start your claim and guide you through the process.

Black handshake icon on a white background

We Re-Shop When Things Change

Rates go up. Families grow. Businesses expand. When your situation changes, we can review your coverage and compare options again, without making you start from scratch.

arrow

One Agency for Everything

Home, auto, boat, farm, business, and life insurance can all be handled by one local team, even if your policies are with different companies.

Independent and Local Since 1952

Being independent is only half of it. We’re also right here in Dover. Our team lives in this community and knows its rivers, farms, and back roads, and we still like to see the properties we insure in person. You can call us, email us, or stop by the office. Walk-ins are always welcome.



When Ted Sills founded this agency in 1952, the idea was simple: treat people right and give them honest advice. Three generations later, independence is how we keep that promise.

Two overlapping speech bubbles, one with a question mark icon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Aerial view of suburban homes beside a road, lined with trees and a field
  • What is the difference between an independent agent and a captive agent?

    An independent agent works with multiple insurance companies and can compare their coverage and prices for you. A captive agent represents only one insurance company and can only offer that company’s products.

  • Does it cost more to use an independent insurance agency?

    No. You don’t pay a fee to work with us. Independent agents are paid a commission by the insurance company you choose, which is already built into the cost of your policy.

  • Can an independent agent save me money on insurance?

    Often, yes. Because we can compare quotes from several companies, we can look for the best combination of coverage and price for your situation. Every situation is different, but having options gives you a better chance of finding a good fit.

  • Can I keep all my policies with one independent agency?

    Yes. Even if your home, auto, and business policies are with different insurance companies, our team can manage all of them for you.

  • What happens if my insurance company raises my rates?

    Give us a call. As an independent agency, we can review your coverage and compare options from other companies to see if there’s a better fit.

See What Independence Can Do for You

Let us shop your coverage and show you your options. There’s no pressure and no cost to ask.