Meet the Sills Insurance Agency Team

Real people, right here in Dover, who know your name and your policy.

The Folks Behind the Phone

When you call Sills Insurance Agency, you won’t get a phone tree or a call center three states away. You’ll get one of us. Our team is small on purpose. We know our clients, we know this community, and we take the time to get your coverage right.


With 75 years of experience to draw from, everyone on our team shares the same goal: giving you honest advice and the kind of service you’d expect from a friend.

Our Team

How Our Team Can Help You

Person under umbrella with shield and checkmark icon, suggesting protection or insurance coverage

Our Agents

Our agents help you find the right coverage. They’ll learn about what you need to protect, shop multiple insurance companies, and walk you through your options in plain English. When it makes sense, they’ll come out and see your home, farm, or business in person.

Person under umbrella with shield and checkmark icon, suggesting protection or insurance coverage

Our Customer Service Team

Need to add a car, change your address, get a certificate of insurance, or ask a question about your bill? Our customer service team handles the day-to-day details, so your policy keeps up with your life.

What We Believe In

Three coworkers collaborate over documents at a table in a bright office, with a laptop and coffee jar nearby.
Black phone handset with ringing signal lines on a white background

We Pick Up the Phone

Our clients would rather talk to a person than fill out a form, and so would we. Call us, and you’ll talk to someone on our team.

Two people shaking hands with a speech bubble above them.

We Tell It Straight

If you don’t need a coverage, we’ll tell you. If you’re missing something important, we’ll tell you that too.

Black handshake icon on a white background

We Show Up

We still like to see what we insure. Taking the time to look at your property means your coverage fits what you actually own.

Black clock icon with a circular arrow, suggesting refresh or time

We’re in It for the Long Haul

Many of our clients’ parents and grandparents insured with us. We work every day to earn that kind of trust from the next generation.

Hands holding a heart with a person icon inside

We Don’t Take Ourselves Too Seriously

We’re a laid-back bunch, and we like to laugh. Insurance is serious business, but talking to us doesn’t have to be.

Family-Owned Since 1952

Ted Sills started this agency more than 70 years ago, and three generations of his family have carried it forward. Learn more about our history, our mission, and what makes an independent agency different.

Let’s Talk About Your Coverage

Have a question or ready for a quote? Give us a call, send us a message, or stop by our Dover office. Walk-ins are always welcome.