Your family, your home, your truck, your boat, your business. These are the things you’ve worked hard for, and figuring out how to protect them shouldn’t feel like a second job. That’s where we come in. For more than 70 years, we’ve helped our neighbors find the right coverage and been there for them when it counts.

About Sills Insurance Agency

Family-owned and operated in Dover, Tennessee, since 1952

Three figures in a circle, with raised arms forming a supportive group icon

Since 1952

Three outlined people with stars above them, representing top-rated users or a team award

3 Generations

Black-and-white outline of a building with a central entrance and windows

Independent Agency

Three Generations, One Hometown

Ted Sills opened our doors in 1952, in the years after World War II. His idea was simple: treat people right, give them honest advice, and be there when they need you. More than seven decades later, that idea hasn’t changed.



Ted’s family kept it going. His sons spent their working lives here, and today his grandson, Tom Myers, carries on the work as the third generation to serve this community.

That kind of history shows up in our client list. Many of the families we insure have been with us for generations. Kids and grandkids come in and tell us they want to be insured where their family has always been insured, and we don’t take that lightly.


We’re a laid-back bunch. We like to laugh, and our door is always open. If you’d rather stop by than call, come on in. We’ll probably have coffee on.

Black quotation marks icon on a white background

“We have families whose children and grandchildren come in and tell us they want to be here, because this is where their family has always been insured.”

- Tom Myers, Owner

Our Mission

At Sills Insurance Agency, our mission is to protect the people and places that make our community home, with honest advice, personal service, and the kind of care you’d expect from a neighbor who’s been here since 1952.

What We Stand For

Aerial view of a small town square with streets, trees, and historic buildings, including a white church tower.
Black hand holding a light bulb with rays above it, symbolizing an idea or innovation

Service First

Customer service has been our top priority since day one. When you call, you’ll talk to someone who knows your name and your policy, not a call center.

Black hand icon with sparkles, suggesting cleanliness or magic touch.

Honest Advice

We’ll tell you what you need and what you don’t. We’re old-fashioned enough that we still like to see what we insure in person, so the advice we give fits your property, your business, and your life.

Black handshake icon encircled by two curved arrows, suggesting agreement or partnership.

Lasting Relationships

We aren’t interested in one-time transactions. We want to be the agency your family trusts for decades, just like the families who have been with us since the beginning.

Black house and small white house silhouettes on a white background

Rooted in Our Community

We live here, work here, and know this area’s rivers, lakes, farms, and back roads. Local knowledge helps us find coverage that fits life in Stewart County and the surrounding area.

The Advantage of an Independent Agency

We aren’t tied to a single insurance company. As an independent agency, we work with multiple carriers, so we can compare options and find coverage that fits your needs and your budget

  • Choice:

    You get a range of policies and price points to choose from, not a one-size-fits-all plan.

  • Expertise:

    We take the guesswork out of insurance by explaining your risks and options, and we advocate for you with the insurance company.

  • Service:

    From your first quote to your first claim, you’ll work with the same friendly local team.

Jim Myers
Black quotation marks icon on a white background

“We’re a laid-back bunch. We like to laugh. It helps the day go by.”

- Tom Myers, Owner

Rick Allen Insurance Agency is an independent agency. We represent Nationwide, Progressive, Foremost, and other top-rated carriers — which means when you come to us for a quote, we're shopping the market for you, not defaulting to the one product we're licensed to sell.


It doesn't cost extra to work with an independent agent. It just means you've got someone in your corner who's working for you rather than for a carrier's quota.

Welcome, New Neighbors

More families are discovering what we’ve always known about this part of Tennessee. If you’ve recently moved from Nashville, Clarksville, or anywhere else, we can help you set up home, auto, renters, or bundled coverage. Even if you don’t know us yet, folks around here have trusted us for a long time.

Proudly Serving Dover and the Surrounding Area

From our office in Dover, we serve individuals, families, and small businesses throughout Stewart County, Houston County, Henry County, and surrounding Tennessee communities.

Black location pin icon on a white background

Sills Insurance Agency

 211 Donelson Parkway, Dover, TN 37058

 Monday–Friday, 8:00 AM–4:30 PM

 Walk-ins welcome

Insurance Solutions We Specialize In

Person under umbrella with shield and checkmark icon, suggesting protection or insurance coverage

Personal Insurance

Home Insurance · Auto Insurance · Home and Auto Bundles · Boat and Watercraft Insurance · Renters Insurance · Umbrella Insurance

Black briefcase icon with a handle and clasp on a white background

Business Insurance

Business Owners Policy · General Liability · Commercial Property · Workers’ Compensation · Farm Insurance · Commercial Trucking

Black heart icon with two people silhouettes and a small checkmark badge

Life Insurance

Term Life · Whole Life · Universal Life · Final Expense · Annuities

Let’s Talk About Your Coverage

Tell us a little about what you need to protect, and we’ll reach out to walk you through your options. No pressure and no jargon, just straight answers from people who’ve been doing this a long time.